By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
News as they happen
  • News
  • Canada
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Science
  • World News
  • Isness
Reading: Systemic Suppression: The CCP’s Silent Elimination of Alternative Confucianism
Sign In
Font ResizerAa
News as they happenNews as they happen
  • News
  • Canada
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Science
  • World News
  • Isness
  • News
  • Canada
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Science
  • World News
  • Isness
Have an existing account? Sign In
© Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
systemic-suppression:-the-ccp’s-silent-elimination-of-alternative-confucianism
Systemic Suppression: The CCP’s Silent Elimination of Alternative Confucianism

Systemic Suppression: The CCP’s Silent Elimination of Alternative Confucianism

Last updated: August 4, 2025 7:50 pm
By Carlo J.V. Caro
37 Min Read
Share
SHARE

The most subversive threat to Xi Jinping’s regime may not come from liberalism but from Confucianism: not the curated slogans in textbooks, but the unassimilated traditions that posit moral authority above the state. This final essay in the Simulated Sagehood series examines how heterodox Confucian frameworks like Jiang Qing’s Political Confucianism have been quietly extinguished. 

What survives is a managed inheritance: tradition retained as spectacle, but stripped of its capacity to judge or constrain.

Xi Jinping often invokes the language of Confucianism to project cultural continuity and civilizational depth. But behind the ceremonial vocabulary lies a system of epistemic control – one that quietly disables any version of Confucian thought that could challenge Chinese Communist Party (CCP) supremacy.

The most prominent casualty of this containment is the school of Political Confucianism associated with Jiang Qing. In his 2012 book “A Confucian Constitutional Order,” Jiang envisioned a tricameral legislature: a House of the Nation (rooted in cultural legitimacy), a House of the Worthies (anchored in moral wisdom), and a House of the People (reflecting popular will) – all governed by tianli (Heavenly Principle), not by Marxist historicism or liberal democratic sovereignty. 

This model doesn’t just diverge from CCP doctrine; it subverts it. By positing a moral order that transcends politics, it implies that the party is not the final arbiter of truth. That tension was openly acknowledged during the 2010s, when a symposium in the Cambridge Journal of Law & Religion described Jiang’s vision as an attempt to “re-center political legitimacy on a pre-Marxist moral cosmology” – a direct affront to the Leninist idea that the CCP alone defines what is right.

For a time, particularly under Hu Jintao’s relatively more pluralistic leadership between 2004 and 2012, this alternative Confucianism had space to breathe. It appeared in respected journals like Reading (读书), Open Times (开放时代), and the Beijing Cultural Review (北京文化评论). Scholars such as Kang Xiaoguang and Chen Ming proposed civil-service exams based on virtue rather than rote testing, and envisioned ritual-based models of governance as Chinese alternatives to both Soviet-style bureaucracy and Western liberalism. A 2018 issue of Culture and Society looked back on this moment as “the adolescence of mainland New Confucianism” – a moment of possibility that was quickly being eclipsed.

Under Xi, that window has closed. In 2015, internal guidance from the Central Propaganda Department and the National Press and Publication Administration instructed editors to avoid “speculative institutional schemes derived from pre-modern systems” unless they could be reframed in terms of socialist values. The impact was immediate. Jiang’s Guoxue Academy in Guizhou lost its legal registration in 2016. Leading academic journals began quietly rejecting submissions that treated tianli as a living political concept. Searches for “儒教宪政” (Confucian constitutionalism) on CNKI, China’s national academic database, started returning no results.

When a 2017 overseas article revisited the idea of a “House of Sages,” the Global Times fired back with a familiar script, denouncing unnamed “reactionary fantasies” that “smuggle political ambition under antique robes.” The message was clear: any intellectual architecture that implied limits on Xi’s authority would be treated as latent rebellion. 

Behind the rhetoric stands real coercive power. The 2018 Party Disciplinary Regulations include “improper discussion” (妄议中央) as a punishable offense – on par with bribery and dereliction of duty. In 2023 alone, over 110,000 officials were formally disciplined; many were cited not for corruption, but for ideological misalignment.

This is not censorship in the classical sense; rather, it resembles a filter. The key terms of Confucian ethics – xiao (filial piety), zhong (loyalty), and he (harmony) – are still present in textbooks and slogans, but only after being gutted of their metaphysical weight. What remains are empty vessels, repurposed to reinforce the logic of Xi Jinping Thought. Meanwhile, any notion of an external moral order – whether tianli, tianming (the Mandate of Heaven), or the right to remonstrate – is treated as illegible. These ideas are simply excluded: from curricula, journals, policy documents, and political imagination.

What has been eliminated, in effect, is not Confucianism as heritage – but Confucianism as judgment. The language of tradition remains, without the possibility that tradition might hold power to account. This elimination doesn’t take the form of persecution. It works through silence, through what is no longer published, no longer taught, no longer translated into institutional reality.

How China Is Transforming Space Power
As Geopolitical Competition Heats up, China Is Eyeing the Caribbean 
Trump Hosts White House Meeting on Gaza’s Future
Scrapping the Temporary Foreign Worker Program Is Common Sense
US Trade Rep Expects No ‘Enormous Breakthrough Today’ in Latest China Talks
Share This Article
Facebook Email Copy Link Print
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    5 + 6 =

    You Might Also Like

    ai-investment-by-aussie-firms-surges-142-percent-in-2-years
    Artificial IntelligenceAustralia NewsAustralia Top NewsBusinessCompaniesDigital PrivacyTechUncategorizedWorld News

    AI Investment by Aussie Firms Surges 142 Percent in 2 Years

    By Naziya Alvi Rahman
    1 Min Read
    wall-street-review:-stocks-sell-off-amid-confusion-over-economic-data-and-fed-policy
    BusinessEconomic PoliciesEconomyMarketsStocksTariffsUncategorized

    Wall Street Review: Stocks Sell Off Amid Confusion Over Economic Data and Fed Policy

    By Panos Mourdoukoutas
    1 Min Read
    2-men-charged-with-attempted-murder-after-11-year-old-shot-in-regina:-police
    CanadaFeatured Canadian NewsTop Canadian NewsUncategorizedWorld News

    2 Men Charged With Attempted Murder After 11-Year-Old Shot in Regina: Police

    By Chandra Philip
    1 Min Read
    News as they happen

    We influence thousands of users and are the number one business and technology news network on the planet. Newsguard delivers everything you need to know to live your best life, best tech trend, traveling passion and more…

    Categories

    • The Escapist
    • Entertainment
    • Bussiness

    Quick Links

    • Advertise with us
    • Newsletters
    • Complaint
    • Deal

    @Newsguard – Codeus Design. All Rights Reserved.

    Welcome Back!

    Sign in to your account

    Username or Email Address
    Password

    Lost your password?