In November 1777 (when American independence was by no means assured), the Continental Congress recommended a day of thanksgiving to God. George Washington’s army would be at Valley Forge very shortly. The proclamation called on the people to acknowledge God’s providence, confess their sins, and pray for the preservation of their liberty. It even went on to speak of forgiveness through Jesus Christ. This is one aspect of Thanksgiving that has pretty much vanished from the standard Pilgrim, turkey, and football narratives. Thanksgiving holds a unique place in the American experience. Christmas and Easter are Christian holidays that are celebrated all over the world. The Fourth of July is very much an American holiday, albeit one that is based on a political event. Our Thanksgiving combines the national experience with a distinctly religious purpose. Canada has its own Thanksgiving, of course, but American Thanksgiving has taken on a character inextricably linked to our founding, our constitutional government, and our struggle for national survival. The story didn’t start with the federal government. There were harvest festivals and days of prayer prior to independence, and the 1621 Pilgrim/Wampanoag encounter is part of that history. The national holiday didn’t simply evolve into an annual reenactment of a meal in Plymouth. Its real significance came about through the statesmanship of successive generations. In 1789, George Washington declared a day of thanksgiving, following the establishment of the new constitutional government. His reasons for the declaration were independence, peace, the adoption of the Constitution, and the enjoyment of civil and religious liberty. He also asked the people to pray for forgiveness of their national transgressions and that their government might be one of just and constitutional laws. Gratitude, as he saw it, carried obligations for both rulers and the people. Abraham Lincoln carried on that tradition under circumstances far more dreadful than Washington could have imagined. On Oct. 3, 1863, he issued the proclamation that established the precedent for an annual national Thanksgiving in November. The Union had won at Gettysburg and Vicksburg, but the war was far from over. Americans were still killing Americans; unionism and slavery had split the nation asunder, and no one could at that point have any idea what the republic would be like when the war was over. The proclamation, drafted by Secretary of State William H. Seward and issued by Lincoln, thanks God for the harvests, the industry, the increase of the population, and the preservation of the very elements of national life that we have been able to maintain in the midst of the war. It recognizes that God has dealt with us in anger for our sins, and yet has not forgotten His mercy. It calls upon the people to be penitent, to care for the widows and the orphans, and to seek the healing of the nation’s wounds. Lincoln didn’t think that national Thanksgiving required a declaration of national innocence. His Second Inaugural Address went even further in terms of his thoughts on the war, slavery, and God’s judgment. He felt we owed thanks for the blessings we had received, we owed repentance for the wrongs we had done, and we owed responsibility for the future. The holiday didn’t stop developing with Lincoln. In 1941, after years of confusion about the date, Congress fixed it as the fourth Thursday in November, and President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the joint resolution. Seven years later, President Harry S. Truman’s proclamation put the holiday into the context of a nation that had survived World War II and was now entering the Cold War. He spoke of freedom, of human dignity, and of the country’s capacity to help those in other countries who were suffering. Thanksgiving was thus linked to what the country should do with its abundance. This history is important because Thanksgiving has increasingly become part of the struggle over what young Americans should believe about their country. Since 1970, Native Americans have observed a National Day of Mourning at Plymouth. The organizers of the day state very clearly that it is a political protest, and their present statements see the holiday as part of a wider critique of American society and its history. The issue comes in when historical inquiry is used as a tool to get young people to view Thanksgiving essentially as a day of national shame. That would be a case of handing them a political verdict on their inheritance rather than encouraging them to look at the full history of it. The whole of this controversy is really focused on Plymouth in 1621, with very little attention to the subsequent evolution of Thanksgiving as a national institution. Whatever you make of the Pilgrims, the proclamations of the Continental Congress, Washington, Lincoln, and Truman all helped to establish a much wider tradition. They linked gratitude with liberty, with Providence, with the responsibilities of a nation, and with the responsibilities of Americans to each other. Washington and Lincoln had both faced the issue of national sin. Neither saw the recognition of national sin as a reason to forgo Thanksgiving. Their view was that the nation was under moral obligations that went well beyond its own wishes, its own power, or its own achievements. Within a Christian framework, the blessings of national life are gifts rather than evidence of moral superiority, and loyalty to the nation in no way supersedes our duty to God. The inheritance we have received as Americans includes freedom of conscience, a constitutional form of government, extraordinary opportunity, and a very real record of the challenges of living up to those principles. To understand the inheritance, we must acknowledge the challenges as much as we must acknowledge the achievements in order to preserve it. There’s also a duty to future generations. We’ve inherited institutions, freedoms, traditions, and opportunities that we didn’t create in their entirety. We have a responsibility to preserve the good, to fix what has failed, and to leave something better than we inherited. In the 250th year of the country, Americans should know the difference between the history of their national inheritance and teaching their kids to hate it. Thanksgiving reminds us that the American republic is a thing to be gratefully received, honestly judged, and carefully passed on. That’s a far better purpose for the holiday than national condemnation.