For more than 150 years, Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution has dominated scientific thought on the origin of species. The concept that the spectrum of species has evolved over billions of years through a series of random beneficial mutations has garnered widespread acceptance. But some scientists have pushed back on that idea for decades, arguing that Darwin’s theory doesn’t stand up to modern understanding of the complexity behind even single-celled organisms. Axe is the author of the book “Undeniable: How Biology Confirms Our Intuition That Life Is Designed.” Axe compared Darwin’s model to placing little pieces of metal into a cement mixer and expecting more and more complicated machines to emerge. “You can’t roll the metal bits around in a cement mixer and be popping out first a toaster and then you know, a blender, and then a scooter, and then an internal combustion engine. That’s just sheer nonsense,” he said, adding that a single biological molecule is far more complicated than an internal combustion engine. Agreeing With Darwin Axe made it clear that Darwin didn’t get it totally wrong, in his opinion. He said the idea that differences in organisms may give one portion of a population an advantage—and allow them to outbreed and replace other members of the same species—is an observable truth. He cited an example from everyday life: When a virus hits, people eventually develop immunity to some variants, allowing other variants to thrive. The same phenomenon is observed—in a man-made way—by producing new breeds of dogs through honing in on certain characteristics, and encouraging members of a puppy population with those traits to reproduce. Thus, Dalmatians and Great Danes exist. “So yes, [natural] selection will affect the future state of a population. What natural selection and random mutation will not do—or any other natural cause—is invent a whole new kind of organism. It just won’t happen,” Axe said. “That’s because we now know that the amount of information you need to make, say, new protein folds, to reconfigure cell types, to reconfigure tissues, to make an entirely new body plan is way beyond the paltry amount of information you can get by a normal population.” Jekielek probed that a little, pointing out that Darwin’s theory is based on tiny incremental changes taking place over vast amounts of time, and leading to complex systems. Axe explained that his research shows there has not been enough time, and the number of living organisms that have crawled the Earth is too small, for Darwin’s theory to work. The Experiment The idea first came to him while he was getting his doctorate from Caltech in the 1990s. Afterwards, Axe and his wife headed to Cambridge for postdoctoral work, where he hoped to put his theory to the test. “I was kind of arrogant … I had told my wife … we were gonna go to Cambridge. I was gonna topple Darwinism in a few years, and then we'll come back and do something else.” That turned out to be easier said than done. The experiments were more difficult than he anticipated, he said. He’d also overestimated the impact his work would have, and “grossly underestimated the number of people who had been contributing to this for decades” before his work was published. “So I was interested in looking at a single gene in a bacterial cell, messing it up, and then putting it in what we call a ‘library.’” A gene library is created by taking snippets of genetic material and placing them in bacterial or yeast cells. “You make millions of these genes, you put them in bacterial cells, and then let the cells tell you whether that gene still works,” Axe said. “And that way, you can actually … quantify the fraction of these messed up versions of a gene that work, and then you can do a little bit of math and say, ‘Well, what if the whole thing were nothing but a mess? What’s the likelihood that out of a mess you would pull something that works?’” Axe was looking for a single protein chain, performing a single function, since that is the “smallest level of innovation” found in living things, and far less complex than what is needed to make a new cell, a new organ, or a “genuinely new organism.” The experiment showed that the odds that such a “mess” would randomly produce a sequence of amino acids that folds into a functional protein chain was “one in 10 to the 77th power, which is one in 100,000 trillion trillion trillion trillion trillion. Highly unlikely, mind-bogglingly unlikely.” Even billions of years are not enough time to produce the level of complexity seen on Earth, he said. That number also exceeds the estimated number of organisms that have lived on Earth, he said, which is only 10 to the 40th power. The Price of Dissent Axe said he was able to proceed with his work relatively quietly, although not in secret. He had secured funding from the Discovery Institute, a think tank that funds intelligent design research. But the experiments were taking place at a time when the question of intelligent design—and whether it should be taught in schools—was being hotly debated in the UK legislature and on BBC radio. Sir Alan Fersht was head of the Medical Research Council’s Center for Protein Engineering, where Axe was working as an independent research scientist. He later said, in an interview with New Scientist, that another researcher suggested he get rid of Axe, but he refused. “I said I was not going to throw him out. What he was doing was asking legitimate questions about how a protein folded,” Fersht said. Nevertheless, Axe was eventually removed, and he claims that was to avoid drawing scrutiny to the Medical Research Council Center. Axe said he understood that Fersht had a legitimate desire to avoid controversy in his lab and wished they had sat down together to discuss it. “What he did instead was have his assistant email me and say, ‘We’ve run out of space, and you need to go.’ That’s how it worked.” He published a paper on the subject in the Journal of Molecular Biology in 2004, which went through peer review. He thought the results of his experiment clearly showed it was time to “move on from the Darwinian era,” but learned it was not so simple. “It turns out there are power structures in the scientific establishment,” he said. “So there might be people who read my paper who actually did abandon their confidence in Darwinism, but they’re very careful not to speak out about it because they would lose their job. So there’s all these complexities to how science actually works.” Axe went on to found the Biologic Institute in 2005, which continues his research to show that life has an intelligent designer. He is also a professor at Biola University. Axe’s argument that complex biological structures point to an intelligent designer is naturally controversial, especially since he is a Christian. Jekielek asked how he deals with accusations of bias. “If you’re not a Christian, you’re also biased. It’s just a different bias,” he said. “So we all have a bias, and it is possible for all people to allow their bias to prevent them from getting fair consideration to an idea that they view to be in conflict with the way they’re thinking. That’s a possibility for me. It’s a possibility for someone who’s criticizing me as well.”