Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski, a former co-chair of Parliament’s special joint committee on medical assistance in dying (MAID), says he supports a Conservative proposal to split the government’s latest MAID legislation into two parts. The proposal would allow MPs to vote separately on whether to permit advance MAID requests and whether to permanently exclude people whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness from eligibility. “Conservatives are split on the issue,” Powlowski said Nov. 18. “I think people may have had conflicting views on those two issues.” Powlowski, who is a medical doctor, has in the past opposed legislation by the Liberal government to expand MAID. Bill C-41, tabled by Justice Minister Sean Fraser on Oct. 27, proposes amending Canada’s Criminal Code in order to allow people with degenerative conditions, including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and dementia, to file an advance request for the administration of MAID before they lose the ability to consent as their conditions worsen. It would also permanently exclude people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from eligibility for MAID. On Nov. 17 the House of Commons voted 225 to 89 on second reading to refer Bill C-41 to the House committee on justice and human rights for further study. Some Conservative MPs say they support the mental illness exclusion but expressed reservations about advance eligibility and called for it to be examined further. Many among the Conservatives voted against the bill. Tory MP Ben Lobb, who voted to send the bill to committee, said further clarity is needed on advance requests, as well as safeguards for people with mental illnesses. Fellow Conservative MP Corey Tochor, who also voted to send the bill to committee, said he is concerned about euthanasia policy in Canada. “The expansion of MAID is wrong for our society, and it’s a nuanced position that every Canadian is very sensitive to,” Tochor said. “I just believe it’s horrendous what we’re doing with MAID in Canada today.” The government has until March 17, 2027, to pass the legislation before MAID eligibility is scheduled to expand to people whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness, due to the previously passed Bill C-62 in February 2024. However, Bill C-62 which expanded MAID to include people whose sole underlying condition was mental illness, was delayed by three years at the time of passage to give provinces and territories more time to prepare their health-care systems. On Nov. 16, the Liberal government moved to limit debate on Bill C-41. MPs approved a motion from Fraser allowing one further day of second-reading debate, despite opposition calls for more time to examine the proposed changes. Canada legalized MAID in June 2016, initially limiting eligibility to people whose natural death was reasonably foreseeable. Parliament expanded eligibility in March 2021 through Bill C-7, which established two categories. Track 1 applies to people whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable, while Track 2 applies to those with serious, incurable medical conditions whose natural death is not reasonably foreseeable. Track 2 requires additional safeguards, including a minimum 90-day assessment period. Under current rules, eligible applicants must be at least 18, have a serious and incurable illness, disease or disability and be in an advanced state of decline that can’t be reversed.