There is a crisis in Canadian education. Much has been said recently about the fact that one in three 9-year-olds cannot read and that 15-year-olds are two to three years behind their recent peers. But, to mix metaphors, the root of the problem is upstream. Paul seems amazed that students are flocking to a curriculum that begins with Homer’s “Odyssey,” moves forward in time to James Joyce’s “Ulysses,” then circles back to end with “The Iliad.” Along the way, students encounter Montaigne, Shakespeare, Spinoza, Baldwin, Dante, and Plato. One student observes, “A lot of what we get out of this class is the human experience, and you can’t get that out of AI.” Another calls it the only Harvard class where students challenge one another for not having done the reading (that’s rare at Harvard?) Professors nominate books for the curriculum and lead seminars on works books from disciplines outside their own. In other words, they co-teach and learn alongside their students. Paul describes the course as “distinctly old school.” It’s a welcome alternative for students tired of AI content and hungry for a deeper understanding of themselves and the world. “At the heart of the humanities, after all, is humanity.” But here’s what’s irksome. Harvard’s Hum 10 began in 2008. Thirteen years earlier, Malaspina University College (now VIU) had established an entire BA program in Liberal Studies. I began teaching there in 2005. What did we offer? Much the same as what Harvard now celebrates. Our courses were team-taught and seminar-based. Students read a book each week, attended lectures and participated in discussions. The first required core course, LBST 350, often began with “Genesis” and the “Odyssey,” followed by Plato’s “Republic,” Sophocles, Aristophanes, Aristotle, Catullus, Augustine, and Boethius. LBST 360 explored medieval and early modern writers, while LBST 370 brought students into the 20th and 21st centuries. Elective courses allowed students to explore particular thinkers, artists, philosophers, and scientists in greater depth. Across the curriculum, we examined fundamental questions about human life and meaning from multiple perspectives. Students wrote several papers each term, received detailed comments from professors, and rewrote their work. There was no AI to do the thinking for them. We expected them to read carefully, write thoughtfully, and engage seriously with challenging ideas. They learned to discuss difficult questions with one another, marshal evidence to support their claims, and sometimes disagree without being disagreeable. In a free society, citizens need these skills. It might sound presumptuous, but we pursued wisdom alongside students whose souls longed, as ours did, for truth and beauty. We also took learning beyond the classroom. Each spring, we offered a course on the Renaissance in Italy. The department was the first at VIU to create these “field” schools, and we ran them on a shoestring budget at reduced pay in addition to our regular teaching load. Students read Dante and Machiavelli while living in Florence. We visited galleries and cathedrals, and marvelled at the art of Giotto, Donatello, Brunelleschi, Gentileschi, and Michelangelo. For some students, it was their first trip beyond Vancouver Island. Many described the experience as life changing. In essence, Harvard now offers a version of what VIU—an open-access, publicly supported university in Nanaimo, British Columbia—provided for decades. And here’s the bitter irony—VIU discontinued its Liberal Studies BA in 2026. Some LBST courses fortunately continue within the philosophy department, but the degree program is gone. But the desire to know our own humanity, to seek truth in friendship with others, and to experience beautiful things together, never goes out of fashion. That desire is more urgent now than ever as we confront the challenge to our own humanity that AI represents. So I’m happy to praise Harvard’s Hum 10 and every other program that preserves this kind of education. It clearly answers a need that students recognize, even if they struggle to articulate it. But I cannot help feel annoyed to see Harvard celebrated for offering students something we had here for decades, then tossed aside. Sadly, there are few such programs left in Canada. We need more of them, not fewer.