A Manitoba judge has directed the province’s NDP government to disclose who was responsible for excluding Tesla vehicles from the provincial EV rebate program and explain why the decision was made. The government has 10 days to comply, meaning it has until Nov. 23 to explain the decision that Tesla asked the court to reverse in May. Tesla alleged procedural unfairness, unreasonableness, and an improper purpose inconsistent with the program’s objectives in its filing to the court, arguing that the exclusion of Tesla vehicles was tied to U.S. tariff disputes and lacked transparency. The Manitoba government has argued the exclusion was an unreviewable budgetary decision and objected to Tesla’s effort to compel disclosure of the record. Neville criticized the provincial government’s initial filing of six documents, saying it showed “a baffling coyness” about its decision-making process. “They seem to be suggesting that the mere assertion that these decisions were reflected in a budget document should shut down any further review by this court,” she wrote. “Yet the disputed record filed with the court sheds no light whatsoever on the question of who made the Tesla exclusion decisions, how they made the decisions, why they made the decisions, and whether these decisions are reviewable.” She called the government’s position that the court should identify the decision-maker for itself “untenable.” “I cannot make that determination without knowing who the decision-maker was,” the judge said. She added that it was “highly improbable” that the decision to exclude Tesla was made at the same time as the finance minister delivered the 2025 Budget Speech. Rebate Program Finance Minister Adrien Sala said on provincial budget day in 2025 that Tesla was being removed from the EV rebate to “Trump-proof our economy” and demonstrate a “commitment to be elbows up.” Chinese EVs were excluded at the same time. Tesla said in a May 2026 court filing that Manitoba’s decision to keep its vehicles out of the EV rebate program unfairly cost local buyers at least $560,000 in incentives and ran counter to the program’s environmental objectives. Tesla’s legal counsel noted at an October court hearing that Premier Wab Kinew told Tesla CEO Elon Musk earlier this year to “get Donald Trump to stop the tariffs, and then we can talk about the EV rebate.” Tesla’s lawyers argued that because the province provided no formal consultation or written rationale, Kinew’s public statements are the clearest evidence of why Tesla was cut. They contended that tying a provincial environmental rebate to U.S. trade disputes and Elon Musk’s political ties goes against the stated purpose of making EVs affordable. Neville explicitly noted Tesla’s argument that “in the absence of a proper record” it makes sense for the applicant to rely on media reports and public remarks. She said Tesla is “entitled to seek to challenge a decision affecting its interests.” The judicial review has been set for Dec. 22 and a motion by the government to strike the Tesla application will be heard at the same time. The Epoch Times attempted to contact the NDP government and Tesla’s counsel for comment but did not hear back before deadline.